Making state government in Ohio simpler, faster, better, and less costly. .
Crime fighters to get findings on evidence in days rather than months

IN BRIEF: Ohio's crime labs analyze evidence and DNA for police departments and county sheriffs. It's crucial work that needs to be done right and done quickly. A Kaizen event has prompted major improvements that maximize efficiency.

STANDARDIZATION: Three processes at three labs have been turned into one.

GREATER EFFICIENCY: The new process involves 103 fewer steps, reducing the time from submission of evidence to final report by as much as 83%.

SAVINGS: The switch to online reporting will save $57,000 per year.

A subgroup from the team begins developing a “clean-sheet redesign” of the process. Two other subgroups did the same, then they compared their ideas and developed a unified approach.

Ohio is working smart in the fight against crime. Thanks to big improvements at the state's three crime labs, law enforcement agencies will get faster findings regarding their submissions of forensic evidence and DNA samples.

Projections show that once the improvements are fully in place, forensic testing could take as few as 14 calendar days from receipt of evidence to issuance of a findings report (72% faster). With DNA testing, the average time could go as low as 21 days (83% faster). And when evidence includes forensic and DNA components, the projected average time could drop to 35 days (70% faster).

The faster processing is good news for Ohio's crime fighters. It will speed up investigations and help prosecutors move more quickly to build their cases and put criminals behind bars. But most of all, it does right by the victims of crime by ensuring that justice is brought about sooner rather than later.

The improvements were developed at the Bureau of Criminal Identification and Investigation (BCI). A team of 15 people began by creating detailed flow charts of the three different processes used by labs in London (main office), Richfield, and Bowling Green. Then they turned the three workflows into one, creating a simplified process for all locations that maintains high quality with 55% fewer steps and 50% fewer handoffs.

One of the key improvements is at the front end of the new process. Easy checks are being put in place to ensure that forensic samples and all required information are complete when first submitted by law enforcement agencies. This prevents loopbacks, rework, and resulting delays.

Another key improvement is at the end of the new process. Final reports from BCI will increasingly be provided in electronic format, replacing the hard-copy versions with all their paper, postage, and extra handling. Savings of $57,000 are expected each year with the paperless approach.

Also, the team's analysis found that scientists were spending too much time on activities that could be done by technicians and office assistants -- such as cleaning the work areas and mixing chemicals. Staff duties have been adjusted so that lab scientists can focus on work that calls for their specialized skills. This is allowing them to process cases more quickly, and it adds up to a wiser use of payroll dollars.

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine met with the team during its Monday morning launch to affirm his support and underscore the project's importance. He returned on Friday for a briefing by team members that went into detail on their analysis, improvements, and results.

The full week was filled with nonstop work involving a team of leaders from BCI, scientists and other staff from all three locations, a former detective and deputy sheriff who is now a special agent in the crime scene unit, an assistant attorney general with prosecutorial experience, and others. BCI Superintendent Tom Stickrath filled a key role, meeting with the team several times each day to get updates, provide input, and eliminate roadblocks on the spot. Staff from IT, purchasing, and elsewhere were brought in to answer questions specific to their functions.

The five-day format is known as a Kaizen event. It uses methodologies and tools for achieving big gains in efficiency, savings, and customer satisfaction. Kaizen is used extensively at successful private-sector companies throughout the world. In Ohio state government, it is among the tools that are a part of the LeanOhio improvement effort. Staff from the LeanOhio Program Office facilitated the BCI Kaizen event.

This report was published May 3, 2011. Projected and actual results may have changed since then. For the latest info, contact LeanOhio or BCI.
    BCI contacts:
    Mike Velten: (330) 659-4600 ext. 276
    Dr. Elizabeth Ann Benzinger:
    (740) 845-2508

Ohio Attorney General
Bureau of Criminal Identification and Investigation
April 2011

Team members

Team members: Mike Velten, Liz Benzinger, Lewis Maddox, Lynn Bolin, Jen Duvall, Amy Wanken, Becki Hager, Bryan White, Casey Agosti, Brenda Gerardi, Kristen Slaper, Russ Edelhelt, Emily Draper, Julie Trackler, Jonathan Blanton

Click here for more photos
  Download the team report-out PDF
  Download a 2-page article PDF

"BCI team was able to significantly reduce inefficiencies..."  click for the full article